Discover the best pizza restaurants in Middlesex County
Middlesex County offers pizza lovers a true taste of Connecticut’s celebrated regional styles, from thin, charred New Haven–inspired pies to classic family-friendly options. The county’s blend of shoreline and inland towns means you’ll find everything from hearty slices near the water to cozy spots perfect after a day of exploring.
Ad Placeholder
Riverside pizzeria known for wood-fired Neapolitan-style pies, bright salads and a focused menu of appetizers and desserts. Expect chewy, slightly charred crusts, inventive toppings like corn & chorizo, and a solid local beer and wine list.
Train-themed pizzeria known for crisp, chewy pies, playful upstairs model train layouts, and kid-friendly vibes. Reviewers praise inventive specialty pizzas, solid salads, vegan cheese and a broad beer selection that keeps locals coming back.
Alforno Trattoria serves wood-fired pizzas and handmade pastas in a warm, casual room. Regulars rave about crisp, airy crusts, robust Bolognese, fresh seafood starters and attentive staff who make each meal feel thoughtfully prepared and satisfying.
Brickside Pizza in Ivoryton turns out wood-fired, thin-crust pies that balance New Haven–style char with a tender, chewy interior. Regulars praise the sauce-to-cheese balance, cupped pepperoni, inventive toppings and family-friendly takeout and outdoor seating.
A neighborhood takeout spot in Durham known for thin, charred pies and bright tomato sauce. Family-run, casual counter service with a few picnic tables outside and a menu of panini, grinders, meatballs and classic Italian comfort dishes.
Coastline Brewing Company & Pizzeria pairs a rotating lineup of local beers, seltzers and ciders with wood-fired, thin-crust pizzas and bar snacks. The nautical taproom and roomy patio create a casual, family-friendly spot for drinks and pizza.
Whether you’re strolling through a bustling college town or relaxing by the Connecticut River, Middlesex County’s pizza scene is never far away. Many pizzerias offer convenient parking and easy access, making it a breeze for families and travelers to enjoy a delicious slice.
Ad Placeholder
A family-run New Haven–style apizza spot on the Shoreline, known for a thin, crisp crust, bright house sauce and smooth, non-oily cheese. Casual, kid-friendly dining with a broad menu that includes clam, white, and specialty pizzas.
Krust Pizza & Bourbon Bar offers a delightful selection of unique, delicious pizzas and craft cocktails in a cozy, trendy atmosphere. Locals rave about the thin-crust pizzas and extensive bourbon offerings.
Mondo serves up delightful, thin-crust brick oven pizzas and a variety of delectable dishes, drawing locals together for a satisfying dining experience in a welcoming atmosphere.
Old Saybrook Pizza Palace offers cozy dining with a diverse menu spotlighting fresh, flavorful pizzas and seafood. With a warm atmosphere and friendly staff, it’s a beloved local favorite.
Nestled in Essex, Privateers Pizza is celebrated for its thin, crispy crust and a warm atmosphere, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Known for its delightful Italian fare, Rossini's offers an inviting atmosphere combined with exceptional service and a focus on allergen-friendly options, making it a favorite among locals.
The influence of New Haven–style apizza can be found throughout Middlesex County, with crisp crusts and fresh toppings drawing locals and visitors alike. It’s a great place to experience Connecticut’s pizza trail without the crowds of the bigger cities.
Ad Placeholder
Sicily Coal Fired Pizza is a vibrant restaurant in Middletown, known for its delicious dishes, exceptional service, and lively atmosphere perfect for families and friends.
Vero Cucina offers a delightful blend of Italian cuisine that locals adore. Known for its cozy atmosphere and mouthwatering dishes, it’s a favorite spot for family gatherings and special occasions.
Along the shoreline, you’ll discover pizzerias that lean into coastal flavors, while inland towns often feature tavern-style pies and classic Greek pan pizzas. No matter your preference, Middlesex County delivers a welcoming slice for every palate.
Ad Placeholder