About Fuoco Apizza

Fuoco Apizza brings a New Haven–inspired approach to Cheshire with a coal-fired oven that creates pronounced char, a crisp exterior and an airy interior.

Reviewers repeatedly praise the balance of cheese and sauce, the sprinkle of pecorino, and the oven’s ability to produce quick, flavorful pies.

Service leans counter-first with a compact dining area and heavy takeout demand; staff are described as friendly and accommodating.

While some customers note variability with wet toppings or oil, most guests celebrate the focused flavors and the dough’s light chew that hold up from first bite to the last.

Location & Contact

What to Expect

The menu leans into classic New Haven apizza: margherita, a standout cheese pie, the Fuoco Special, burrata-topped options and a white clam influence echoed in reviews.

Several guests single out the mozzarella pie, margherita with pecorino, and the Buffalo chicken as particularly memorable.

Expect a tomato sauce that reviewers call bright and slightly tangy—less sweet than many places—and a crust that ranges from paper-thin and charred to a touch thicker yet airy.

Sides like wings, penne vodka, Caesar salad and mozzarella sticks round out a menu built to pair with crisp, coal-fired crusts.

Hashtag Pizza Fact's

The Economics of Pizza: A Billion-Dollar Industry

Pizza's immense popularity has propelled it into a billion-dollar global industry, with an estimated value of $145 billion. This economic impact is supported by a vast network of over 78,000 pizzerias in the United States alone. The industry includes both large chains and independent establishments, highlighting pizza's universal appeal and its role as a staple in the food economy.

Statistics

From the Community

Fuoco Apizza has built a strong reputation in Cheshire for New Haven–style pies cooked in a coal-fired oven, collecting enthusiastic responses across hundreds of reviews.

The restaurant’s 4.5 Google rating and a stream of repeat visitors point to a consistent focus: charred, thin crusts, a bright tomato profile and a finishing sprinkle of pecorino that many reviewers praise.

As George DeVita noted, "The crust was perfectly crunchy, light, and not greasy at all," a sentiment echoed by others who cite a firm yet airy bite.

Counter service and limited indoor seating keep the operation lean, and reviewers emphasize takeout strength while warning that heavily topped pies can steam and grow soggy.

Signature offerings called out repeatedly include the margherita, Fuoco Special, burrata pies and a standout mozzarella pie.

Michael Eastwood described the experience as featuring a "stunningly thin, blackened and chewy crust, light and tangy fresh sauce, and a winning cheese blend of quality moz and pecorino," capturing the texture-and-flavor balance that keeps locals and visitors returning.

Overall, Fuoco reads like a neighborhood apizza shop that aims for bold, coal-driven flavors rather than delicate, fussy plating.

Why Locals Love It

Michael Eastwood ★★★★★

Michael praises the pies as "stunningly thin, blackened and chewy," and that description matters locally because it nails the New Haven apizza standard many Cheshire diners chase. That firm-but-airy crust and tangy sauce offer the kind of comfort and consistency neighbors want for regular pizza nights and for introducing visitors to a Connecticut-style pie.

George DeVita ★★★★★

George singled out that "the crust was perfectly crunchy, light, and not greasy at all," which resonates with families and commuters looking for a clean, flavorful slice. Locals value that crisp texture and bright sauce—it's the sort of dependable pizza people recommend to friends and happily drive back for on repeat visits.

Malik Abdul-Rahmaan ★★★★★

Malik's account—returning three days later and calling the mozzarella pie possibly "the best I've ever had"—speaks to the strong word-of-mouth here. For the community, that kind of enthusiasm turns Fuoco into a regional draw: residents appreciate an accessible spot that can compete with New Haven staples while remaining their own local favorite.

Customer Reviews

George DeVita
★★★★★ 2 months ago

"My recent visit to Fuoco Pizza in Cheshire, CT, was a great decision! We ordered two large cheese pizzas, which came to about $50 with tax and Foxon Park sodas – a brand I always appreciate for its variety. The women working upfront were friendly and welcoming and helped answers questions we had. The cheese pizza itself was outstanding!!! The crust was perfectly crunchy, light, and not greasy at all. You could clearly taste the fresh sauce, and I think what was the sprinkle of Pecorino ? or Parmesan? on top was the perfect finish. Really great!! Seriously, this is great pizza and well worth a visit. I'm so glad we went!"

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Dan Herrick
★★★★ 4 months ago

"I was looking forward to going here after a video I saw. Fuoco Apizza has less indoor seating than I was hoping for, it was sprinkling and cold so we weren't going to ear outside. We got a large cheese pizza, great presentation. It was a almost non existent crust, too thin, no firmness. Great undercarriage and was still delicious but not like the classic Connecticut Apizza Restaurants."

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Jimbo Williamson
★★★★★ 4 months ago

"Unbelievable!! Stopped in here on tour with a band, and our whole crew loved the apizza! The owner came and hung with us, and was such a genuinely nice dude, and the passion he has for his pizza shines through. It. Was. Fantastic. Check these photos, that coal fired oven makes magic! Thanks so much George!"

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Daniel Karimian
★★★★★ 3 weeks ago

"I finally had the chance to come here on my birthday weekend, and they did not disappoint! I felt bad that we got there an hour before closing time, but the staff didn't mind one bit! They were more than happy to let us pick a table and happily put our order in once we were ready. Very friendly too! The pizza came out hot, fresh, and fast. And let me tell you, it's some of the best NH style "apizza" I have had in a long time! I had the chicken Florentine and my girlfriend had the burrata. Both pies were amazing! I see why Portnoy gave them his blessing! Get yourself a pie from Fuoco! You won't be disappointed!"

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo

Hashtag Pizza Fact's

Pizza's Adaptability: A Canvas for Creativity

Pizza serves as a culinary canvas, adapting to various cultures and culinary innovations. From gourmet toppings like truffles and arugula to dietary variations like gluten-free and vegan options, pizza continually evolves to meet changing consumer preferences. This adaptability ensures its place as a dynamic and enduring favorite in the ever-changing landscape of global cuisine.

Food Science

Frequently Asked Questions

What does "New Haven style" crust taste like at Fuoco Apizza?

New Haven style at Fuoco means a very thin, slightly chewy crust with noticeable char from a coal-fired oven. Reviews mention a crisp outside and airy interior, so expect firm edges, a little blackening, and a light chew under the toppings.

Is the tomato sauce sweeter or more tangy?

Many reviewers describe Fuoco’s tomato sauce as bright and less sweet—more tangy and slightly acidic. It sits forward enough to balance cheese and toppings without being cloying.

How oily are the pizzas?

Some guests noted a heavier oil presence on certain pies, especially those with lots of cheese or toppings. Others found the cheese pie "not greasy at all," so oiliness may vary by pie and toppings.

Do veggie-loaded pizzas get soggy?

A few reviewers observed that pies with many wet vegetables can steam and come out a bit soggy if the oven isn’t at peak heat. If you want extra crisp, consider lighter veggie toppings or ask staff about cook style—Not listed; call to confirm.

What are people saying about the margherita and mozzarella pies?

Reviewers repeatedly praise the margherita and straight mozzarella pies for balanced cheese-to-sauce ratios, fresh mozzarella pull, and a finishing dusting of pecorino that boosts savory notes.

Is the burrata pizza creamy or more restrained?

The burrata pies are described as creamy and rich, adding a soft, luxurious texture on top of the charred crust that many reviewers single out as a highlight.

How does the Buffalo chicken pizza taste?

Reviewers find the Buffalo chicken pizza flavorful without overwhelming heat—enough buffalo flavor to be distinct while still allowing the crust and other ingredients to shine.

Are the white pies like the clam or ricotta very garlicky?

White pies such as clam and ricotta-based options are praised for balanced flavors; reviews note garlicky and herb accents in some white pies but emphasize the coal oven’s char as the defining feature.

Do sides like wings and mozzarella sticks taste homemade or more classic fast-food style?

Guests mention wings and mozzarella sticks as solid sides that complement the pizza. Reviews describe them as flavorful add-ons that pair well with the coal-fired pies rather than upscale restaurant fare.

Is there anything special about their pasta or grinders?

Penne vodka and the chicken parmesan grinder appear on the menu and have positive mentions in reviews for portion and flavor. If you’re curious about sauce richness or spice level, reviewers say the penne vodka is on point and hearty.

Connecticut's Premier Pizza Destinations

Current location in red, 8 nearest in blue, all others in gray

Fuoco Apizza

461 W Main St, Cheshire, CT 06410
4.5
(666 reviews)

Explore Nearby Restaurants

Click any restaurant to view details