About Domenic's and Vinnie's Pizza

Domenic's and Vinnie's is a Waterbury staple where pies come in very large sizes and familiar, old-school flavors.

The kitchen turns out both thin, crunchy tavern slices and denser, chewy crusts with noticeable charring, while the sauce and cheese draw consistent praise from regulars.

Service is warm and attentive — reviewers mention friendly servers and quick turnaround — and the dining room fits families and groups.

The mood is cozy and casual, the kind of place people return to for reliably tasty pizza and big portions.

Location & Contact

What to Expect

The menu centers on classic pies: cheese, pepperoni and sausage are frequently singled out for strong cheese, a balanced, mildly seasoned sauce and hearty topping portions.

Specialty options that reviewers mention include mashed potato (with bacon and cheese), buffalo chicken and white clam, plus square-cut large pies and a Caesar salad that can feed a crowd.

Expect choices between thin, tavern-style slices and a thicker, rustic dough with chew and char.

Hashtag Pizza Fact's

Pizza Delivery: A Modern Convenience

The convenience of pizza delivery has revolutionized how we consume this beloved dish. The rise of pizza delivery services began in earnest in the mid-20th century, with innovations such as the Domino's HeatWave bag ensuring hot, fresh pizzas reach customers' doors. Today, digital platforms and apps have streamlined the ordering process, making pizza more accessible than ever. This convenience is integral to pizza's popularity, catering to fast-paced lifestyles while maintaining the comforting and convivial nature of sharing a pizza at home.

Culture

From the Community

Domenic's and Vinnie's on Wolcott Street reads like a neighborhood pizza shop that has kept its formula: generous pies, attentive service and a loyal following.

Locals praise the crusts — from thin, crunchy tavern slices to a hearty, old‑world dough with chew and char — and many single out the sauce and cheese as consistent standouts.

One longtime fan wrote, "Never soggy, always tasty without being salty," and noted the shop has been around for 75 years, a testament to staying power.

Another recent diner said, "My boyfriend and I had dinner here Saturday night!

It was absolutely delicious!!" Servers and staff get frequent nods for friendliness and quick service, and diners appreciate the oversized portions that make leftovers a regular bonus.

The menu mixes basics like cheese and pepperoni with playful choices — mashed potato pie, buffalo chicken and a white clam option — giving both traditionalists and adventurous eaters reasons to come back.

Whether picked up piping hot in a paper bag or eaten in, the pizza emphasizes solid, familiar flavors and real ingredient quality.

Why Locals Love It

Luciana Minnocci ★★★★★

Luciana remembers growing up on this pizza and calls it "the absolute best," praising pies that stay firm and never soggy. That long-term loyalty signals more than nostalgia: it's proof the place maintains consistent dough rising, sauce seasoning and cheese quality that keeps Waterbury families coming back for decades.

Candice Sisbarro ★★★★★

Candice highlighted portion size and friendly staff, saying, "It was absolutely delicious!!" That mix—huge slices, hearty salads and welcoming service—matters to local families who want big value and a fuss-free meal together on a weekend or after events.

Mike Fratea ★★★★★

Mike travels from out of town because he loves the sauce and spicy homemade sausage; his habit of freezing pies to enjoy later shows locals prize flavor that holds up. That devotion speaks to a community built around reliably bold toppings and a sauce profile people remember.

Customer Reviews

Candice Sisbarro
★★★★★ 4 months ago

"My boyfriend and I had dinner here Saturday night! It was absolutely delicious!! We got a large pepperoni, medium sausage and a large salad. The portions are huge. The large salad could feed a family of 5 and the large pepperoni could feed more than that. You get a big bang for your buck here!!! We definitely ordered way too much food lol, but we took home amazing leftovers. The staff was very friendly and we can't wait to go back!!"

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
M. BEE
★★★★★ 5 months ago

"I got the mash and bacon and cheese 💯! They were all friendly. Large was like XL small was like a MEDIUM …"

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Carla Gonzalez
★★★★★ 4 months ago

"We dined in with 3 adults and four kids. We had Demi as our server, she was wonderful, quick and very accommodating! Mashed potato pizza was about 7/10 , cheese was 10/10!!!!"

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Michael Maloney
★★★★ 7 months ago

"Been here 1x. Neighborhood joint with good thin crust tavern-style pizza"

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo

Hashtag Pizza Fact's

The Evolution of Frozen Pizza

Frozen pizza has come a long way since its inception in the 1960s, revolutionizing convenience in the pizza industry. Initially criticized for its lack of flavor and texture, advancements in food technology have enhanced quality, offering artisanal-style options with thin crusts and gourmet toppings. Today's frozen pizzas cater to a broad spectrum of dietary preferences, including gluten-free and plant-based varieties, allowing consumers to enjoy the convenience of pizza at home without compromising on taste or dietary needs.

Food Science

Frequently Asked Questions

What does the crust taste like here?

They make a few crust styles. Some pies are thin and crunchy like tavern slices, while others use a thicker, old‑world dough that's chewy with a pronounced crust and nice charring. Both are mentioned by customers.

Is the sauce spicy or mild?

Most reviews describe the sauce as balanced and somewhat mild but seasoned in an old-school way. People say it tastes classic and complements the cheese and toppings rather than overwhelming them.

How is the cheese on the pizza?

Reviewers praise the cheese as very good quality—melty and flavorful. Several people specifically called the cheese a highlight, especially on plain cheese and pepperoni pies.

Do they have unique pizzas like mashed potato or clam?

Yes. Customers mention a mashed potato pie with bacon and cheese and a white clam pizza. These specialty options get called out by name and are part of what regulars order.

Is the sausage spicy or mild?

The homemade sausage gets compliments for big flavor; one reviewer described it as spicy. If you like bold sausage, that comment suggests it has a noticeable kick.

Are toppings generous?

Yes. Multiple reviews say pies come with lots of toppings and large portions—one review even noted a large could feed many people—so slices feel substantial and filling.

What about buffalo chicken pizza?

Buffalo chicken is listed among popular items and reviewers said it was good, so it’s an option for people who like tangy, spicy poultry toppings on their pie.

Do they cut pies square or in wedges?

Both styles are mentioned. Customers recall hefty square-cut large pies and standard slices, so you may see square-cut presentation at times.

Is there a good salad to go with pizza?

Yes. Reviewers talk about a very large Caesar salad that can feed a family, making it a sensible side to balance cheesy pies.

Is this like New Haven pizza?

Some reviewers from New Haven say they’re hard to please but call Domenic's and Vinnie's "something special." That suggests it won praise from New Haven pizza fans without claiming to be the same style.

Connecticut's Premier Pizza Destinations

Current location in red, 8 nearest in blue, all others in gray

Domenic's and Vinnie's Pizza

505 Wolcott St, Waterbury, CT 06705
4.4
(380 reviews)

Explore Nearby Restaurants

Click any restaurant to view details