About Sally's Apizza

Known for its bustling energy, Sally's Apizza is a New Haven favorite, drawing locals and tourists alike with its coal-fired pizza that boasts a perfect balance of flavors. The relaxed yet lively vibe makes it an ideal spot for families, groups, and solo diners. Guests often praise the attentive service, ensuring that even with wait times, the overall experience remains enjoyable. This historic establishment embraces its roots while continuously delighting patrons with its signature pies and comforting atmosphere.

The restaurant's charm is further enhanced by its friendly staff who are dedicated to providing an exceptional dining experience. Many visitors share their memorable moments of savoring the iconic mozzarella and tomato pies or the intriguing clam pizza, which showcase Sally's commitment to quality and freshness. The environment resonates with the rich pizza culture of New Haven, making every visit a celebration of good food and warm company.

Location & Contact

What to Expect

Sally's Apizza is celebrated for its stellar menu, featuring dishes such as the New Haven Original Clam Pie, which is often described as a must-try for seafood lovers. Guests rave about the classic mozzarella and tomato sauce pie, known for its perfectly charred crust and balanced flavors. The Cannoli Pie and Caesar salad also receive high marks for their distinctive tastes and enjoyable textures. With fresh, high-quality ingredients, each pie promises to deliver a memorable experience.

Other specialty offerings, like the Basil Pizza and unique combinations like the Bacon, Apple, Sage Pie, highlight the restaurant's creativity while ensuring every guest finds something to delight their taste buds. Overall, Sally's strives to maintain a perfect harmony of flavors that keeps visitors coming back for more.

Hashtag Pizza Fact's

Pizza: A Culinary Chameleon

Pizza's adaptability is one of its greatest strengths, allowing it to evolve with changing culinary trends and dietary needs. From gluten-free crusts to vegan cheese options, pizza continually reinvents itself to meet diverse consumer preferences. This chameleon-like quality ensures its enduring relevance in the ever-changing landscape of global cuisine.

Food Science

From the Community

Sally's Apizza in New Haven has solidified its reputation as a pizza destination, drawing long lines of eager diners. As noted by Dalton Anderson, "I waited in line for 90 minutes... It was absolutely worth the wait. 8.7/10." The anticipation of sampling their coal-fired pies energizes visitors, creating an unforgettable experience even before the first bite.

People rave about the amazing flavor profiles, particularly with the mozzarella and tomato sauce pie and clam pizza. Aditya Malik emphasized the sauce, stating, "It's incredibly flavored and fresh!" This sentiment resonates with the heart of Sally's, which prides itself on fresh ingredients and unique offerings.

Despite occasional long waits, the consistent quality of food and warm atmosphere makes it truly special. Many guests, like Renauld Brown, leave noting that the flavors blend better after a few momentsβ€”an indication of the promising tastes found at Sally's. Whether you're dining in or planning takeout, it’s an essential stop for pizza lovers in Connecticut.

Why Locals Love It

Dalton Anderson β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

For many locals, waiting in line is part of the charm of Sally's. Dalton's experience captures this perfectly: all the anticipation builds up to a taste that leaves a lasting impression. He sums it up with, 'It was absolutely worth the wait,' echoing the community's sentiment that true culinary treasures require some patience.

Aditya Malik β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Aditya's comment about Sally's incredible sauce spotlights the pride locals take in their pizza heritage. His recommendation to try the Basil Pizza and the freshness of the ingredients reinforces how Sally's sets itself apart, making it a go-to for anyone looking to savor authentic flavors distinctly tied to New Haven's identity.

Renauld β€œNauldoNation” Brown β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Renauld highlights the fresh and hot pizzas from Sally's, pointing out how the flavors amalgamate beautifully over time. This reflects the rich culinary culture of New Haven, where waiting is not just about patience, but also about the communal joy of sharing great food, making Sally's a cherished gathering place.

Customer Reviews

Dalton Anderson
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… 6 days ago

"Like many a tourist, I had Sally's Apizza on my list because of Dave Portnoy. I was blown away when I turned the corner to a line at the end of the block. The anticipation could not be higher! We ordered two large Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce Pies, a small Bacon, Apple, Sage pie, a Caesar Salad, and a Gassosa to drink. The mozzarella and tomato pie is king for a reason. A sweet and fresh tomato sauce on a light, coal-fired crust does all the heavy lifting. The bacon and apple was unique, but I don't love white cheese pizzas and the apple is too nuanced for me. The Caesar salad was incredible, and I pinched myself to ensure it wasn't my taste buds boosting flavors because of the wait. The dressing isn't too strong, and coats each leaf of fresh lettuce perfectly while dashed with just the right amount of croutons. And the gassosa complemented the pizza as I hoped it would, so I'm a big fan of the "Italian Sprite." The amount of food was perfect for a party of five. Angel was a great server. He under-promised and over-delivered. When we were seated, he let us know pies would take an hour. He brought our salad and drinks out quickly, and we were pleasantly surprised when food was out in about 30-40 minutes. He was quick on refills, and checked on us regularly. I enjoyed how even though there's a lot of anticipation from patrons to get into the restaurant, and then once in receive food quickly, the staff keep the anxiety down and manage the time. They set the tone, and it makes for a great dining experience. Great service all around. The atmosphere is everything I could hope for. A seasoned pizzeria part of the soul of a city, with fans old and new who wait for hours to get a table and share a pie. In total, I waited in line for 90 minutes, then 40 to get the pizza. It was absolutely worth the wait. Would I do it again? I'd honestly probably plan ahead and do takeout, but for my first time, I'd wait again. It was a legendary experience and well worth the memories. One Bite: 8.7/10"

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Aditya Malik
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… a month ago

"Sally's is one of the big 3 here in CT and each pizza spot does something incredible that others don't. For Sally's, it's the sauce. It's so incredibly flavored and fresh! I highly recommend getting the Basil Pizza, the cheese melts right in with the sauce, and the pesto is a great fresh touch. The pros: amazing sauce, friendly service The cons: insanely long lines (we waited almost 2 hours to sit, and another 30-35 for the pizzas after sitting) They mix online orders with restaurant orders so truthfully you're better off ordering for takeout if you can, rather than waiting the full 2hrs in line. But the freshness of the sauce might be worth it!"

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Alexander Katsabanis
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… 2 months ago

"Myself and a group of 3 friends flew up from Miami 8:00 am just to make it here by lunch. I can’t begin to explain how good this pizza was. The service was fantastic. They had an old timer greeting us while we waited outside, and he really did make us feel comfortable and at home (nice touch). The gentlemen recommended we order β€œThe Fire Bird”. It did not disappoint. Aside from getting yourself an original cheese, you must order this fire bird!! Amazing spot. My favorite pizza on the planet thus far. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!! I would hopefully love to come here again someday. The flight was worth it, the wait was worth it. The day was a 10/10."

Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo
Pizza review photo

Hashtag Pizza Fact's

The Royal Birth of Pizza Margherita

Pizza Margherita owes its name to Queen Margherita of Savoy, who visited Naples in 1889. Legend has it that pizzaiolo Raffaele Esposito crafted a special pie to honor her, featuring toppings of tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil to mimic the colors of the Italian flag. Whether or not this tale is entirely accurate, it symbolizes the shift of pizza from a peasant food to a dish worthy of royalty, marking its ascent within Italian cuisine.

History

Lombardi's: The Pioneer of American Pizzerias

Lombardi's Pizza in New York City is celebrated as the first licensed pizzeria in the United States, dating back to 1905. Initially, it served tomato pies to the Italian immigrant community before transforming into a full-fledged pizzeria. Lombardi's not only introduced Americans to the joys of pizza but also laid the foundation for New York's iconic pizza culture, which features large, foldable slices beloved by locals and tourists alike.

Ad Placeholder

Connecticut's Premier Pizza Destinations

Current location in red, 8 nearest in blue, all others in gray

Sally's Apizza

237 Wooster St, New Haven, CT 06511
β˜…4.3
(5051 reviews)

The Coal-Fired Charm of New Haven Apizza

New Haven's signature 'apizza,' pronounced "ah-beets," is distinct for its coal-fired, chewy crust and minimalistic toppings, with the white clam pie being a standout creation. Frank Pepe's Pizzeria Napoletana, opened in 1925, and Sally's Apizza, opened in 1938, are icons of this style, often sparking debates over which serves the best pies. This regional specialty underscores Connecticut's pride in its pizza heritage, drawing pizza enthusiasts from all over to taste its unique flavors.

Ad Placeholder

Explore Nearby Restaurants

Click any restaurant to view details

The Great Tomato Transformation

Initially met with suspicion as a potentially poisonous fruit, the tomato's integration into Neapolitan cuisine in the 18th century revolutionized pizza. Its addition transformed a basic flatbread, known simply as 'pizza,' into the vibrant and flavorful dish we recognize today. This pivotal change not only defined the taste profile of pizza but also marked the beginning of its journey from humble street food to global culinary staple.

Ad Placeholder