New Haven Pizza Place

Pizza restaurant

★★★★☆ 4.3

302 reviews $10–20 per person

About New Haven Pizza Place

At New Haven Pizza Place, the ambiance invites diners to relax and enjoy food crafted with care. Patrons appreciate the thin-crust pizzas, often boasting a perfect char, alongside a variety of comforting options like hearty grinders and creative entrees.

The service here is noteworthy, with guests highlighting friendly bartenders and attentive staff who make each visit enjoyable. Whether indulging in a lively trivia night or sharing laughs over pizza and cocktails, this establishment quickly becomes a local favorite.

Location & Contact

Address1377 New Haven Ave, Milford, CT 06460
Websitehttps://newhavenpizzaplace.com
Phone(203) 693-3500
Links Order online · Get directions

What to Expect

The menu at New Haven Pizza Place features celebrated dishes like the Meat Lovers Pizza and the Pepperoni Pizza, both praised for their delicious flavors and perfectly baked crusts.

Hashtag Pizza Fact's

Frozen Pizza: A Convenience Revolution

The advent of frozen pizza transformed the way people enjoy this beloved dish at home, offering a quick and easy alternative to takeout. The first commercially successful frozen pizzas hit the market in the early 1960s, paving the way for a booming industry. Today, frozen pizza sales generate billions annually, with a wide variety of styles and toppings catering to diverse palates around the globe.

Food Science

Menu Highlights

From the Community

New Haven Pizza Place has carved out a beloved niche in Milford's dining scene by specializing in New Haven-style pizza, artfully prepared and charred to perfection. As Ryan M. Carroll noted, "If you like New Haven style pizza... this place is a MUST TRY!" Featuring a welcoming environment and a bar that enhances the dining experience, locals find plenty to enjoy.

Regulars like Matthew Edo praise the custom creations, especially his unique "DonEdo" Steak and Cheese pie. The great atmosphere is often complemented by entertaining staff like Jasmine, who enhances evenings out with fantastic cocktails. After high praise from visitors, Jim Cozad remarked on the flavors and star of the menu stating, "The meats and cheeses used have a bunch of flavor." With such consistent quality and community focus, it’s no wonder New Haven Pizza Place is a treasured destination.

Why Locals Love It

Ryan M. Carroll ★★★★★

As someone who adores good pizza, I found New Haven Pizza Place’s consistent quality of New Haven-style pizza to be exceptional. The locals appreciate that this pizzeria exemplifies the unique tastes associated with our city’s pizza tradition. It’s the ideal gathering spot for pizza lovers.

Tina Arango ★★★★★

Throwing my daughter’s birthday party here was a delightful decision. The warm service and scrumptious pizza make this hidden gem a local favorite spot for special occasions and everyday meals. Everyone could enjoy the space comfortably, making it a joyful experience.

Lisa Franco ★★★★★

Jasmine, our bartender, was the highlight of our visit with her extraordinary service. Genuinely warm and engaging, she creates an inviting atmosphere. People come back not just for the food but for the connection that makes dining special.

Customer Reviews

Ryan M. Carroll

★★★★★ 2 weeks ago

"The first time we went to New Haven Pizza Place over a year ago, part of the bottom was burned. Not just the “char” but burned. Still edible, but importantly, the flavor was very good. And the Caesar salad was great. So, we gave it another try. We’ve now had New Haven Pizza Place a half dozen times, at least. Every single time the pizza is GREAT! We’ve had the pepperoni, mushroom (side note: I don’t ever get mushroom, but this mushroom is fantastic), sausage—I think a few special pies too?—plus, just had the original tomato pie tonight—delicious! It’s all very consistent (and I chalk up that first time as an anomalous off-day). If you like New Haven style pizza (the thin crust, char, etc.), this place is a MUST TRY!"

matthew edo

★★★★★ a month ago

"Have been here over 10x's I am a huge Pizza lover and this place by far has the most amazing pies! Jazz who is the best bartender in the biz had the cook make me my custom "DonEdo" Steak and cheese with peppers and onion pie and it was out of this world!! Its my go to pizza resturant in Milford, come down Monday nights, ask Jazz for the pie and have some cocktails and share laughs and stories."

HybridOfficial

★★★★★ a month ago

"Very nice place to go and eat, especially during the fall season when you feel like grabbing a nice warm pie. And if your looking for some actual good brick oven pizza....Come here...!!! I love the people and the environment, especially Jasmine because she's such kind person. Come out enjoy the food at the New Haven Pizza place in Milford."

Lisa Franco

★★★★★ a month ago

"It was my fiancé and my first time there Jasmine was our bartender, she was absolutely great. We loved talking to her. Our drinks were amazing and so was the food. We made sure that we came back just to see her!"

Hashtag Pizza Fact's

Pizza's Economic Impact

Pizza is not just a culinary delight but also a massive industry, with over 78,000 pizzerias in the United States alone. These businesses, ranging from family-owned shops to major chains, contribute significantly to local economies and employ hundreds of thousands of people. Globally, the pizza market is valued at roughly $145 billion, underscoring its role as a staple in diets and economies worldwide.

Statistics