About Colony Grill - Stamford
Colony Grill keeps the attention on one thing: pizza.
The Stamford spot is known for ultra-thin, crunchy crusts that reviewers describe as crispy and firm rather than cracker-like, often finished with a distinctive hot oil that adds spicy depth.
The menu is intentionally small, which helps the kitchen deliver consistent pies and short waits.
Service and atmosphere pull the experience together.
Reviewers note friendly, fast staff and a cozy, historic bar setting with a good beer selection.
The combination of focused food, upbeat service, and comfortable pub vibes is why many diners return.
Location & Contact
- Address172 Myrtle Ave, Stamford, CT 06902
- Websitehttps://colonygrill.com
- Phone(203) 359-2184
- Links Order online · Get directions
What to Expect
The menu centers on thin-crust bar pies that reviewers praise for crisp edges, cheese that reaches the rim, and toppings placed evenly across the surface.
Signature choices include the Hot Oil pie, Hot Oil with Stingers, pepperoni, onion, mushroom, bacon, sausage, and unique options like corned beef and breakfast pizza.
Hot oil and stingers are repeatedly called out as the defining flavors; guests report pies that hold their structure even with many toppings and arrive with a satisfying crunch and balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio.
Hashtag Pizza Fact's
UNESCO and the Art of Neapolitan Pizza
In a momentous recognition, UNESCO added the art of Neapolitan pizzaiuolo (pizza-making) to its Intangible Cultural Heritage list in 2017. This acknowledgment celebrates the social and cultural value of pizza making in Naples, where it is considered both an art and a tradition passed down through generations. The honor not only highlights the skills of pizzaioli but also underscores pizza's profound cultural impact, marking it as a culinary practice that transcends mere food preparation and embodies a rich cultural narrative.
Menu Highlights
From the Community
Colony Grill in Stamford keeps its focus tight: just pizza and a stout selection of drinks.
The house specialty is an ultra-thin, crispy bar pie, often ordered with the signature hot oil or spicy stingers.
Regulars and first-timers alike highlight a crust that’s firm and crunchy, cheese that reaches the outer edge, and toppings spread with care.
The dining room reads like an old-school pub, and diners appreciate the brisk, friendly service and ample beer choices that complement the pies.
Patron reaction is emphatic and direct: "The hot oil bar pie is what keeps me coming back," says Kevin P, summing up a common reason for repeat visits.
Others offer similar praise — "Yup, still the best damn pizza EVER!" wrote Ruchika after returning decades later.
Reviewers also notice the pies’ construction: as Robert Ruszenas put it, "They were crispy, with toppings well placed and cheese out to the edge."
With a small menu and a focus on technique, Colony Grill aims for the sort of consistency that turns visitors into regulars, especially for those who prize a clean, crunchy crust and a spicy, savory finish.
Why Locals Love It
Customer Reviews
"5/5 for the pizza itself. Reasonably priced, delicious, and definitely in my personal top 10... maybe even top 5. The pizza has more in common with midwest/chicago 'tavern pizza' (thinner crust but still had a decent chew, not crackers like). Good selection of beers both "standard" and local draft. 100% is a "coming here again" next time I am in the area"
"25 years ago we were lucky enough to live near Colony Grill and it was delicious then! But we were young and hadn’t eaten 🍕 around the world! We came back! Yup, still the best damn pizza EVER! Thin crust, firm though and everything, the sauce, the cheese, is in perfect balance! And you do t have a bloat belly on after!"
"I went on a very busy night and was greeted and seated quickly. My server saw me in uniform and asked if i needed a rush on my food as i was on a quick lunch break. I was amazed with the service standards because thats how a restaurant should be run. The pizza was really good."
"Rarely do I leave reviews. There’s enough yapping out there anyway. This place, however?…….killer. Great beers. Great service. Great pizza. That’s the key too. They focus their talents on one thing…….great pizza. No 5 page oversized menu with a bunch of mediocre dishes. Concise and coherent. I ordered a pizza with a bunch of toppings and where it’s usually soggy and floppy, this thing held its own. Crispy and delicious with every bite. Friendly staff great atmosphere and I loved the music even the stuff I didn’t like."
Hashtag Pizza Fact's
Pizza: A Billion-Dollar Industry
Pizza has grown into a colossal global industry valued at approximately $145 billion. This meteoric rise is fueled by the dish's universal appeal, with billions of pizzas consumed annually worldwide. The industry spans independent pizzerias, large chains, and innovative frozen pizza products, highlighting pizza's adaptability and enduring popularity. Whether as a quick fast-food option or a gourmet culinary experience, pizza's economic impact is as significant as its cultural one, making it a staple of both dining and commerce globally.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Colony Grill’s crust different from other pizzas?
Their crust is very thin and crispy but still has a little chew. Reviewers call it firm rather than cracker-like, with a crunchy edge that holds toppings instead of getting floppy.
What is the hot oil and how does it taste?
Hot oil is a spicy finishing oil poured or served with the pie. It adds a warming, peppery kick that reviewers say builds after a few bites and makes the pizza distinctly zippy.
What are stingers and do they go on the pizza?
Stingers are a spicy pepper topping commonly added on pies. Many guests order them on the pizza for extra heat; some reviewers recommend getting them on the pie rather than on the side for best flavor.
Do toppings stay in place on the thin crust?
Yes. Multiple reviewers note toppings are spread evenly and the pies hold together. Even with several toppings the crust remains crisp and not soggy.
Is the cheese all the way to the edge?
Yes. Several guests mention cheese that reaches the rim and crisps at the edge, creating small crunchy, flavorful bites around the outer rim.
Are there unusual pizza options like breakfast or corned beef?
Yes. Reviewers tried items such as a breakfast pizza with egg, sausage, and bacon and a corned beef and cabbage pizza, so the menu includes some unique, savory pies.
Do anchovies work with the hot oil or stingers?
Anchovies are used by some guests for salty brightness. One reviewer recommended the combination of hot oil, stingers, and anchovies as a bold flavor mix that balances spicy and salty notes.
Does the Hot Oil taste the same as New Haven pizza?
Reviewers compare Colony’s pies to New Haven-style but say Colony offers its own take: ultra-thin, very crispy, and with a distinctive hot oil that sets it apart while remaining in the same family of bar pies.
Are slices meant for one person or to share?
Many reviewers say the bar pies are thin and ‘perfect size for one person,’ though several people also order two pies to share so everyone can try different toppings.
What pizzas are most popular at Colony Grill - Stamford?
From the menu, people often pick Pepperoni Pizza and Cheese Pizza, Signature Salad Pizza, Onion Pizza, Guinness, Pizza- Hot Oil Onion Stingers, Corona. Reviews highlight consistency more than novelty, so these are safe, crowd-pleasing choices.
Pizza's Role in Pop Culture
Pizza holds a special place in popular culture, often depicted as the quintessential comfort food in movies, television, and music. From iconic scenes like the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles devouring pizzas to Julia Roberts' character in "Eat Pray Love" savoring a Neapolitan pie, pizza is synonymous with indulgence and joy. Its frequent appearances in media underscore its status as a beloved cultural icon, appealing to people of all ages and backgrounds. This cultural ubiquity reflects pizza's role not only as a meal but as a symbol of shared moments and universal satisfaction.
Ad Placeholder
Connecticut's Premier Pizza Destinations
Current location in red, 8 nearest in blue, all others in gray
Colony Grill - Stamford
The Psychology Behind Pizza's Comfort
Pizza's status as a top comfort food is deeply rooted in its psychological appeal. The combination of warm, doughy crust, savory sauce, and melted cheese triggers pleasure centers in the brain, releasing dopamine and creating feelings of satisfaction and happiness. Additionally, pizza's social aspect—often shared among family and friends—enhances its comforting nature, associating it with positive memories and communal experiences. This blend of sensory enjoyment and emotional connection explains why many turn to pizza during times of stress or celebration.
Ad Placeholder
Explore Nearby Restaurants
Click any restaurant to view details
Remo's
Stamford
0.7 miles away
Westover Pizzeria
Stamford
1.5 miles away
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
Stamford
2.0 miles away
Grigg Street Pizza
Greenwich
5.5 miles away
Dante's Pizza
New Canaan
6.6 miles away
Crust Issues Pizza
Norwalk
6.7 miles away
Colony Grill
Norwalk
7.2 miles away
Jordan's Restaurant & Pizza
Norwalk
8.8 miles away
The Guinness World Record Pizza
The record for the world's largest pizza was set in 2012 in Rome, Italy, with a pizza named "Ottavia" measuring 1,261.65 square meters. Created by a team of five Italian chefs, this colossal pizza was gluten-free and named in honor of the first Roman emperor, Octavian Augustus. The monumental task required over 9,000kg of flour, 4,500kg of tomato sauce, and 4,000kg of mozzarella. This record-breaking achievement highlighted pizza's potential to unite people around a shared love for this iconic dish.
Ad Placeholder